Select Page

FACT-CHECK: Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading

Sep 18, 2024 | 0 comments

Claim

An incident of Love-Jihad; A Muslim man is seen abusing his Hindu girlfriend.

Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 1

[TRIGGER WARNING: VIOLENCE]

Recently, a video depicting a young man assaulting a young woman went viral on social media. The source, a verified account on X (formerly known as Twitter), asserted that the man in the video is of the Muslim community and was violently attacking his girlfriend, who is from the Hindu community. The video had gone viral, with claims of love-jihad by a verified account on X (formerly known as Twitter) (Figure.1). Noting this claim, we undertook an investigation by performing a reverse image search on Google using several key frames from the video.

Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 2
Figure 1 The claim of love-jihad on X (formerly known as Twitter)

Fact

There is no communal angle involved in the video. The video in question actually depicts a brother physically assaulting his sister after he discovered that she had deceived him in order to visit her boyfriend, while neglecting their ailing mother who was left unattended in the hospital.

Process of Fact-Checking

Step-1

Upon coming across the video, a Google reverse image search was run to find the exact information regarding the video.

Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 3

Step-2

The result led us to the post shared by another verified account

Step-3

We analyzed the content of the video and came across several news articles that questioned the source and content of the video.

Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 4
Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 5

Source: News 24 onlineWorld Of Buzz

Step-4

Eventually, our investigation led us to the Malaysian news website Wau Post, (https://waupost.com/teenaged-boy-kicks-beats-up-sister-violently-after-she-allegedly-left-their-bedridden-mum-home-alone-to-go-out/) which provided crucial context for the video. According to Wau, several netizens suggested that the video actually shows a brother assaulting his sister for lying about meeting her boyfriend while neglecting her responsibility to care for their mother.

Further investigation confirmed that the incident occurred at Kota Kinabalu Hospital. We then assessed the credibility of these reports.

Viral video of a Man Thrashing a Woman is Misleading - 6

Source: Wau post

Conclusion

The video, which dates back to October 2022, depicts a brother assaulting his sister in Kota Kinabalu, Malaysia. The altercation took place because the sister had left their bedridden, ill mother unattended to meet her boyfriend. This incident is unrelated to any romantic relationship; both individuals involved are siblings. Hence, this claim is misleading!

About Fact- checking Club

The M.O.P. Fact-checking Club is a student-driven initiative on fact-checking of news stories. The main aim of the club is to build fact checking practice among students. Be a part of our fight against fake news by sending us your queries on WhatsApp at 7358702336.

Join in the conversation

Leave a Comment

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Learn more on this topic

Related Blog Posts